Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Angel's avatar
17hEdited

Alex's favorite color was blue, and his favorite emoji was this: 💙

Every time I see that heart, I tell myself it's For Alex 💙

I'm Angel - Thank you for sharing Alex's story.

Some comments from those who knew Alex:

"Alex wanted his story to be shared, but not like the RNZ article. If anything came from his life, he wanted it to be to educate people on the dangers of eating disorders. Alex's transness only ever came up in the context of his parents not accepting him. He would have had a greater chance to explore his gender identity when he was older. Maybe he would have chosen to medically transition, maybe he would have used the non-binary label again, or maybe he would have detransitioned. Either way, that would have been his choice, and it is a choice that he has been robbed of, because he is not alive anymore. Alex needed love, acceptance and space to figure himself out, and he was denied that...

The original article seems so suggest that 'because social services focused so much on Alex's gender identity, they neglected his eating disorder'. It is deeply ironic then, that all of the conversation now seems to be around Alex's gender identity, and people are neglecting to raise awareness about the eating disorder that killed him."

"Alex was gentle and kind, who just wanted to be seen, heard, and respected by his own parents - those who swore to love him unconditionally upon conception. The very system designed to protect him failed catastrophically, and resulted in the preventable loss of life. Dozens of countries claim to have exceptional healthcare only to offer uncomprehensive care to eating disorder patients, especially those in the LGBTQ+ community. We treat the symptoms, but not the actual cause/root of the pain causing the symptoms. Alex, unfortunately, was no exception...

Alex was transgender, and deserved peace, love, and acceptance for his gender identity, just as all queer kids do. Instead, Alex has now passed on as a direct complication of ignorance and hate. We grieve the loss of Alex, one of our own, and pray that he may find peace in whatever afterlife there may be. Alex deserved so much more than he received from those who swore to love him. Alex will always be remembered for the love he spread, and the kindness he showed. We will keep his memory alive in adherence to his core being, because we saw Alex as the brave, kind, and gentle soul he truly was, not what he was forced to conform to be. Rest in power, Alex."

"I could see how much light, and desire to be alive, to be himself, there was in him. I cannot forgive those who failed to support him and took away his future, and it hurts to see his memory weaponized against those who are the most vulnerable. I just want to see my friend be given respect in death. I want Alex's voice to stay alive."

"Alex was always really kind ... a force that always brought a little bit of solidarity... the good, the dark- it didn't matter... they were a comforting presence...

What I'm trying to say is... they touched those they interacted with, even if indirectly, and I'm still processing that.

I miss them."

Expand full comment
David Farrier's avatar

I just wanted to say thanks for the outpouring here in the comments - it's heartening that Alex's story is being heard.

Also thanks to anyone sharing this story - it's getting out there, and hopefully countering RNZ's narrative.

If you want to go to the BSA over this - here you go: https://www.bsa.govt.nz/complaints/the-complaints-process/

RNZ is government owned - they need to take some responsibility as a public broadcaster.

The journalist, Ruth Hill, has a history of writing about trans issues - with headlines like this: "Number of children prescribed puberty blockers growing"

Of course, over on Facebook, TERF organisations like "Speak Up For Women" respond with posts like this: "RNZ Morning Report has a segment on Puberty Blockers this morning, by investigative journalist, Ruth Hill. This is quite a step for mainstream media, but Ruth Hill has credibility, and her findings are not easy to ignore. We take our hat off to Ruth for her courage in speaking out in a hostile environment. We hope to hear more from her."

So yeah.

The story had an angle, driven by a journalist who - knowingly or not - likes stoking fear about trans issues. And somehow an editor let it get published.

Which IS weird - as even a basic read of that article it was pretty clear how offensive and cooked it was. And from there it was published on Stuff (NZ's biggest site) and 1News, too. Less blame there (some young journo getting a feed from trusted RNZ and just copying and pasting).

But yeah, fuck all this.

We hear you Alex.

David.

Expand full comment
130 more comments...

No posts